Audio-video transformer differences
Differences noted below are between UL 1411, fifth edition with pages dated February 18, 1998 and UL 6500, second edition with revisions dated up to September 28, 2001
| Topic | Requirement | UL 1411 | UL 6500 |
| Marking | Manufacturer's name, trademark, or other descriptive marking | 29.1 | 14.3.1 |
| Type or catalog number | 29.1 | 14.3.1 | |
| Factory identification code -- required if transformer is produced or assembled at more than one manufacturing location | 29.2 | 5.1.k | |
| Enclosure | Material used as all or part of the enclosure (end bells) shall have a minimum flammability rating of V-0 in accordance with UL 94 | 4.1 | - |
| Materials used as part of a fire enclosure shall have a minimum flammability rating of V-2 in accordance with UL 94 | - | 20.2.1 | |
| Potting compound shall have a minimum flammability rating of HB in accordance with UL 94 | 4.3 | - | |
| Encapsulation compound covering exterior surface of a transformer shall have a minimum flammability rating of HB in accordance with UL 94 | 4.4 | - | |
| Lead insulation | Rated for the voltage and temperature reached under any condition of actual use | 5.1.1 | 8.9.1 |
| Rated VW-1 | 5.1.1 | 20.1.2 | |
| Sleeving and tubing | Rated for the voltage and temperature reached under any condition of actual use | - | 8.9.1 |
| Rated VW-1 | 5.3.1 | 20.1.2 | |
| Tape | Flame retardant | 5.3.1 | 20.1.2 |
| Flexible cords | Comply with UL 817 and be rated VW-1 | 5.2.1 | 16.1 |
| NISPT-2 minimum | - | Table 9A | |
| Attachment plug | Shall be polarized type | 5.2.2 | - |
| Comply with UL 498 | 5.2.2 | Annex S | |
| Conductors of a parallel flexible cord of a transformer shall not be split external to the transformer enclosure (end-bells) | 5.2.3 | - | |
| Connections Between leads | Joints not soldered shall be securely connected, i.e., wire nuts, welded, etc. | 5.4.1 | 8.11 |
| Solder joints shall be mechanically secure before soldering | 5.4.1 | 8.11 | |
| Mechanical securement of a lead is not required when separation of the connection does not result in a risk of fire or electric shock | 5.4.2 | 8.11 | |
| Strain relief | Shall be provided so that stress on each individual lead is not transmitted to the connection inside the transformer | 5.5.2 | - |
| Strain Relief Test | 25.1 | - | |
| Openings for wires/flexible cords | Flexible cords or wires connected in the primary circuit shall be free of burrs and fins that may damage the conductor insulation | 5.6.1 | 16.6 |
| Unless a bushing is provided, the edges of an opening in a sheet-metal enclosure shall be rolled or formed | 5.6.1 | 16.6 | |
| Bushings | Shall be secured in place | 5.7.1 | 16.6 |
| Interconnection of windings | (Conductive path resistors) a discrete component that provides a conductive connection between the primary and secondary winding of a transformer shall have a resistance that limits the leakage current in the end use to an acceptable value that does not exceed 12-megaohms. The wattage rating of the component shall be at least ½ watt. | 6.1 | - |
| A capacitor with or without a built-in shunt resistor shall comply with UL 1414 | 6.3 | - | |
| Protective devices | A protective device (fuse, overtemperature and overcurrent protector, eutectic material) employed as part of the transformer shall comply with the requirements for the construction, performance, and use for such a device, i.e., shall be UL Recognized Components | 7 | - |
| Thermal cutouts shall comply with UL 8730-2-9 | - | 14.5.1.1 | |
| Thermal links shall comply with UL 1020 | - | 14.5.1.2 | |
| Fuse-links shall comply with UL 248-14 | - | 14.5.2.1 | |
| Separate current-limiting material | Separate current-limiting impedance's, such as positive temperature coefficient (PTC), shall comply with UL 1434 | 8.1 | - |
| PTC's shall comply with IEC 60738 or UL 1434 | - | 14.5.3 | |
| Resistors complying with UL 1412 may be provided | 8.1 | - | |
| Resistors complying with surge test may be provided. Also, resistors complying with UL 1412 may be provided if the resistance does not differ by more than 20% | - | 14.1 | |
| Live part insulating material | Insulating material for the support of terminals operating at 42.4 volts peak or more or having available power of more than 15 W shall have:
See clause 9.1 for exceptions to the above requirements | 9.1 | - |
| Polymeric or fiber parts in contact with a component located in a potential ignition source (see clause 2.8.11 for definition) circuit shall have a minimum flammability rating of V-2 | - | 20.1.4, table 13 | |
| Bobbin material | Bobbin material must be UL Recognized V-2 at minimum bobbin thickness except where the bobbin thickness is < 1/16-inch. Bobbin material with a thickness < 1/16-inch must be UL Recognized V-2 at 1/16-inch. | 10.1 | - |
| May be rated HB or less if the transformer is encapsulated by material rated V-0 or better | 10.1 | - | |
| Shall have a thickness of at least 0.4 mm | - | 8.8, 14.3.4.1 | |
| Bobbin material must be UL Recognized V-2 at minimum bobbin thickness | - | 20.1.4, table 13 |
UL 1411 insulation requirements
Note: the insulation requirements are based on the type of insulating materials employed within the transformer. The table below provides a summary of the requirements. For complete details a complete review of the requirements in clause 11 is required.
| Topic | Requirement | UL 1411 |
| Coil insulation | Insulation shall :
| 11.3 |
| Equivalent generic materials | Generic materials that have been found to be equivalent to electrical grade paper may be used. | 13, table 13.1 |
| Required locations for coil insulation | Electrical grade paper (having a total minimum thickness of 0.30 mm) or the equivalent of such insulation shall be used between:
| 11.6 |
| Insulation between the primary and secondary windings and between the primary winding and the core shall be:
| 11.7, 11.8 | |
| Insulation between the primary winding lead connections and the shield or the transformer enclosure (end bells) shall be:
| 11.9 | |
| Insulation between the crossover leads and the adjacent winding, transformer enclosure (end bells), or core shall be:
| 11.10 | |
| High frequency transformers | Requirements in clause 11.6 - 11.13 are not applicable to insulation in thin sheet materials, irrespective of its thickness, when used in high frequency transformers if:
| 11.14 |
| Outer-wrap and crossover-lead insulation | Shall not be less than 0.028 inch (0.71 mm) thick. | 12.1 |
UL 6500 insulation requirements
The insulation requirements are based on the type of insulation required (basic, supplementary, reinforced or double insulation), the class of the end-product apparatus, i.e., class I or II, and the type of insulation materials employed within the transformer. In the end-product the apparatus shall provide protection from the user to accessible parts. Accessible parts require two levels of protection against electric shock. This can be achieved by one or more of the insulation types identified below.
The following definitions have been provided for your reference:
- Class I -- product which has provision for grounding (i.e., accessible conductive parts are connected to the protective (earthing) conductor.
- Class II - product which has no provision for grounding.
- Basic insulation -- insulation applied to hazardous live parts to provide basic protection (one level) of protection against electric shock.
- Supplementary insulation -- independent insulation used in conjunction with basic insulation in order to provide protection against electric shock in the event there is a failure of basic insulation.
- Reinforced insulation -- provides two levels of protection against electric shock. A single insulation system equivalent to double insulation..
- Double insulation -- provides two levels of protection against electric shock. Comprised of basic and supplementary insulation.
Note: the table below provides a summary of the requirements. For complete details a complete review of the requirements outlined in clause 8, 13, and 14.3 shall be conducted.
| Topic | Requirement | UL 6500 |
| Protection against electric shock | Insulation of hazardous live parts shall not be provided by hygroscopic materials.
| 8.3 |
| Transformer employed in a class I apparatus -- insulation requirements | Insulation between hazardous live windings and accessible parts or parts intended to be connected to accessible conductive parts, i.e., iron core, shall be separated by basic insulation according to clause 8.8. | 8.8, 14.3.5.2 |
| Compliance of insulation is determined by:
| 8.8, 14.3.5.2 | |
| Transformer employed in a class II apparatus -- insulation requirements | Insulation between hazardous live windings and accessible parts or parts intended to be connected to accessible conductive parts, i.e., iron core, shall be separated by double or reinforced insulation according to clause 8.8. | 8.8, 14.3.5.1 |
| Compliance of insulation is determined by:
| 8.8, 14.3.5.1 | |
| Note: for coil formers (bobbins) or partition walls a thickness of 0.4 mm is required. | 8.8, 14.3.5.1 |
UL 1411 spacing requirements
Note 1: the table below provides a summary of the spacing requirements. For complete details a complete review of the requirements outlined in clause 14 shall be conducted.
Note 2: the spacings identified below are required in addition to the insulation requirements of clause 11.
For various examples of bobbin wound transformers refer to figures 14.1, 14.2, 14.3, 14.4, and 14.5 of the standard.
| Topic | Requirement | UL 1411 |
| Spacings | Spacing shall be provided between:
| 14.1 |
| Spacings shall comply with table 14.1
| Table 14.1 |
Table 14.1
| Potential, volts (rms) | Through air (clearance), (mm) | Over surface | (Creepage) |
| Protected against dirt, (mm) | Not protected against dirt, (mm) | ||
| 0 - 50 | 1.6 | 1.6 | 1.6 |
| 51-150 | 1.6 | 1.6 | 3.2 |
| 151 - 250 | 3.2 | 3.2 | 6.4 |
| Note: the spacings apply to coils, crossover leads, splices, uninsulated lead wires, and any turn of the primary winding to any turn of the secondary winding. The spacings do not apply to turn-to-turn spacings of a coil. | |||
UL 6500 creepage and clearance requirements
Note 1: the table below provides a summary of the spacing requirements. For complete details a complete review of the requirements outlined in clause 13 shall be conducted.
Note 2: the creepage and clearance distances identified below are required in addition to the insulation requirements of clause 8 and 14.3.
| Topic | Requirement | UL 6500 |
| Clearances and creepage distances | Creepage and clearance distances shall be provided between: 1. Primary and secondary windings
| 13 |
| Creepage and Clearance distances shall comply with Figure 9, of the standard | Table 14.1 |
Creepage and clearance distances based on figure 9 of UL 6500
| Potential volts (rms) | insulation type | Through air (clearance) & |
| 120 | Basic or supplementary | 1.5 |
| 240 | Basic or supplementary | 3.0 |
| 120 | Reinforced | 3.0 |
| 240 | Reinforced | 6.0 |
Exception: the creepage and clearance distances in the above table may be reduced by 1 mm for basic and supplementary insulation and 2 mm for reinforced insulation if all the following conditions are met:
- They are not between accessible conductive parts of an enclosure and hazardous live parts, if they can be reduced by external forces, as specified in 9.1.7
- They are maintained by rigid construction
- Their insulation properties are not likely to be significantly affected by any deposition of conductive dust produced inside the apparatus
Creepage and clearances shall not be reduced below 2/3 of the values given in Figure 9
UL 1411 performance requirements
Note: the table below provides a summary of the performance requirements. For complete test specifications a complete review of the requirements outlined in the clause 17, 23, 24, 25, 26, & 27 identified in the table shall be conducted.
| Topic | Requirement | UL 1411 |
| Performance testing | When the following tests are not conducted as part of the transformer, they are to be considered in the end-product.
| 17.3 |
| Dielectric voltage-withstand test | Test specification:
| 23.1.1 |
| Test Location:
| 23.1.1 | |
| Thermoplastic bobbin temperature stability test | Test specification:
| 24.1 |
| Test location:
| 24.1 | |
| Strain relief test on insulated leads | Test specification:
| 25.1 |
| Insulation resistance test | Test specification:
| 26.1 |
| Test location:
| 26.1 |
UL 6500 performance requirements
Note: the table below provides a summary of the performance requirements. For complete test specifications a complete review of the requirements outlined in clause 10 shall be conducted.
| Topic | Requirement | UL 1411 |
| Humidity treatment | Test specifications:
| 10.2 |
| Insulation resistance and dielectric strength | Immediately following the humidity treatment test the sample shall be subjected to the following tests (see clause 10.3):
| 10.3 |
| Test specification:
| 10.3 | |
| Surge test | Insulation between accessible parts or parts connected to them and hazardous live parts shall be subjected to the voltage surge test. | 10.1 |
| Test specifications:
| 10.1 | |
| Test locations:
| 10.1 | |
| Test is followed by:
| 10.1 |






